Crankshaft Sensor vs Camshaft Sensor Failure -A Practical Diagnosis Guide for Garages

Crankshaft Sensor vs Camshaft Sensor Failure -A Practical Diagnosis Guide for Garages

Introduction

Modern vehicles are equipped with sophisticated sensors that help the engine control unit (ECU) manage ignition timing, fuel delivery, and engine performance. Two of the most critical sensors are the crankshaft position sensor (CKP) and the camshaft position sensor (CMP). When either of these sensors fails, it can lead to hard starts, misfires, or complete engine shutdowns. For garages and technicians, accurately identifying the faulty sensor ensures a faster repair, avoids unnecessary part replacements, and builds customer trust. This guide will help you understand the key differences between crankshaft and camshaft sensor failures, along with diagnosis methods for each.

Understanding the role of each sensor

Both sensors are essential for optimal engine performance, but they serve distinct roles in managing timing and combustion.

Crankshaft position sensor function

The crankshaft sensor tracks the position and rotational speed of the crankshaft. It helps the ECU determine:

  • Engine RPM
  • Ignition timing
  • Fuel injection timing

Cause: Signal loss

If the crankshaft sensor fails, the ECU cannot read engine speed or piston position, causing a total system shutdown.

Fix: Sensor and wiring inspection

Check the sensor signal using a multimeter or oscilloscope and inspect the wiring for damage or contamination.

Camshaft position sensor function

The camshaft sensor works in coordination with the crankshaft sensor. It allows the ECU to:

  • Identify which cylinder is on the power stroke
  • Control sequential fuel injection
  • Manage variable valve timing systems

Cause: Timing sync issues

A failing camshaft sensor can cause incorrect fuel injection timing and inefficient combustion.

Fix: Replace faulty sensor or verify alignment

Use diagnostic tools to verify the signal and check the sensor alignment with timing components.

Common symptoms of crankshaft sensor failure

Crankshaft sensor failure usually leads to more critical engine issues that prevent starting or cause stalling.

Typical signs

  • Engine cranks but does not start
  • Sudden engine stalling while driving
  • No RPM reading on the instrument cluster
  • Check engine light illuminated
  • Loss of spark or fuel injection

Cause: ECU safety shutdown

Without accurate crankshaft data, the ECU disables ignition and fuel to protect the engine.

Fix: Replace sensor after verification

Confirm using OBD codes (P0335–P0339) and signal analysis before replacement.

Common symptoms of camshaft sensor failure

Camshaft sensor issues are less severe and often result in reduced performance rather than total failure.

Typical signs

  • Hard starting or extended cranking
  • Engine misfires during acceleration
  • Rough idle
  • Reduced fuel efficiency
  • Check engine light illuminated

Cause: Backup mode operation

The ECU switches to default timing using crankshaft data only, reducing precision.

Fix: Replace sensor and check timing sync

Verify OBD codes (P0340–P0349) and inspect sensor wiring and mounting position.

Key differences between sensor failures

Aspect Crankshaft sensor failure Camshaft sensor failure
Engine start Usually no start Often starts with difficulty
Engine stalling Very common Less common
Severity Critical Moderate
ECU response Cuts ignition or fuel Uses backup strategy
Driveability Engine may shut down Reduced performance

Step-by-step diagnosis guide for garages

Step 1: Scan for diagnostic trouble codes

Use an OBD-II scanner. Crankshaft sensor issues usually show P0335–P0339 codes. Camshaft sensor problems typically return P0340–P0349.

Step 2: Observe live data

If RPM reads zero during cranking, the crankshaft sensor is likely at fault. If RPM is present but symptoms persist, suspect the camshaft sensor.

Step 3: Inspect wiring and connectors

Check for oil contamination, broken insulation, corroded pins, or misaligned sensors.

Step 4: Test sensor output

Use a multimeter or oscilloscope. A healthy crankshaft sensor will produce a consistent waveform; a camshaft sensor should show a signal in sync with crankshaft rotation.

Step 5: Verify timing components

Check timing belts or chains. A worn or misaligned timing system can cause fault codes even if the sensors are fine.

Final thoughts

Camshaft and crankshaft sensors may perform similar roles but their failures have different consequences. For garage technicians, knowing these differences improves repair accuracy, speeds up diagnosis, and enhances customer satisfaction. Want to reduce rework and improve your first-time fix rates? Explore high-quality OEM sensors and diagnostic tools at Autozilla – your trusted source for genuine spare parts online.


Visit Autozilla and find the right parts for your car in just a few clicks.